free geoip

Monday, May 16, 2005

SWOP homepage  

Lou Dobbs Airs Local CAFTA Protest

Last week, leaders from Central American countries came to Albuquerque as part of a tour to promote the Central American Free Trade Agreement (CAFTA). SWOP participated in a protest here in ABQ at the National Hispanic Cultural Center against CAFTA. Lou Dobbs aired footage of the protest.

Of course, Lou partly used the footage to promote his ant-immigrant stance. Sorry Lou, we don't agree with punishing the victims of trade policies that are written by and for transnational corporate interests.

Pasted below are key segments and transcripts of the program.

Key segments (which were accompanied by video footage of the Abq demo and press conference!)

- “However, CAFTA is facing rising opposition in Congress because of large part -- small but vocal groups of protesters all over the country are making their views known.... From Miami to Albuquerque, protesters are taking to the streets to oppose the Central American Free Trade Agreement.”

- “Salvadoran president Tony Saca angered demonstrators in Albuquerque when he dismissed them as uninformed. Protesters countered, they understand CAFTA all too well because they lived through its predecessor, NAFTA, which has left an 11-year legacy of environmental degradation, lost jobs, and increased illegal immigration.”

CNN

LOU DOBBS TONIGHT

Aired May 12, 2005 - 18:00 ET

DOBBS: At the White House today, President Bush met with leaders of six countries included in the Central American Free Trade Agreement. The president said they all agreed CAFTA will promote democracy, peace and prosperity in Central America and the Dominican Republic. The president said CAFTA will create prota (ph), a more level playing field for American farmers, and he said it will bolster manufacturing in our hemisphere.

However, CAFTA is facing rising opposition in Congress because of large part -- small but vocal groups of protesters all over the country are making their views known. These groups are lobbying traditionally pro-free trade lawmakers to vote against CAFTA and those formerly for free-trade. Congressman and senators are starting to have second thoughts.

Casey Wian reports.

(BEGIN VIDEOTAPE) UNIDENTIFIED MALE: CAFTA! CAFTA! We don't have to!

CASEY WIAN, CNN CORRESPONDENT: From Miami to Albuquerque, protesters are taking to the streets to oppose the Central American Free Trade Agreement. This week they have been shadowing a 10-city CAFTA U.S. promotional tour featuring Central American presidents, and sponsored by major U.S. corporations such as Citigroup and Coca-Cola. Scores of grass roots groups from across the political spectrum have mobilized to fight CAFTA saying it will destroy jobs in Central America and the United States.

UNIDENTIFIED MALE: These corporations, they portray themselves as all-American brands and all-American clothing, but when you look at it they really -- rarely have anything made in America.

WIAN: The director of a critically acclaimed 2004 documentary on the loss of American jobs, this year wrote a book critical of CAFTA. Greg Spotts has scant financial support and no organization. Still, he's influencing the debate.

GREG SPOTTS, DIRECTOR "AMERICAN JOBS": We're attacking CAFTA like a hive of bees would attack a grizzly bear. You know, a lot of small forces loosely organized. And I think what drives everybody is a moral conviction that people here and in Central America should be paid fairly for the work that they do.

WIAN: An opinion shared by Don White at the Committee in Solidarity with the People of El Salvador. His group has targeted and helped persuade dozens of lawmakers who voted for previous free-trade agreements to oppose CAFTA.

DON WHITE, CISPES: Our objective is to never have it come to a vote, because we do not believe that President Bush wants the humiliation of a CAFTA vote on the House floor and then be voted down.

WIAN: Salvadoran president Tony Saca angered demonstrators in Albuquerque when he dismissed them as uninformed. Protesters countered, they understand CAFTA all too well because they lived through its predecessor, NAFTA, which has left an 11-year legacy of environmental degredation, lost jobs, and increased illegal immigration.

(END VIDEOTAPE)

WIAN (on camera): As Esteban Torres (ph), a former congressman and supporter of NAFTA put it, we owe it to all those who could be adversely affected by CAFTA to demonstrate that we have learned from our past mistakes. CAFTA opponents say they are confident the agreement will be defeated, despite what the Congressman Dreier just told you, Lou.

DOBBS: Thank you very much, and thank you for adding that point, Casey. Casey -- Casey Wian, from Los Angeles.


Comments:
`Asylum in America: Lou Dobbs Rants: Pass Him the Microphone, No Time for the Facts'

Until Mr. Dobbs touched upon political asylum, a subject I know something about, I respected what I had once regarded as his insightful observations on a multitude of subjects.

But the multitude of distortions he has seen fit to infuse into his commentary on asylum in America, revealed just how little he actually knows.

After providing the gentleman with authoritative, third party, and independently verifiable data on the subject, information he and his producers failed to incorporate into his daily rants, it became apparent just how intellectually dishonest he actually is.

While Mr. Dobbs is entitled to his opinions, presenting distortion as authoritatively accurate, unimpeachable fact, betrays the public whose trust he seeks to earn.

I invite Mr. Dobbs to descend from his sedia gestatoria, invoke intellectual honesty and conduct diligent, objective research before making a fool of himself any further, if only on this one subject.

While we, as Americans, have come to regard stupidity as God given, and constitutionally protected, Mr. Dobbs doesn't qualify for the politician or U.S. Government employee exemption to the rule.

/s/ Michael Pellerin (Princeton, NJ)
 
I agree Mr Dobbs can often be dishonest to his audience. EXAMPLE: He often ties the two parties together, saying they are both willing to pass legislation that encourages outsoursing of jobs. That is a LIE! AFL / CIO leader John Sweeney as a guest on the show actually corrected him on this on the show one time.

During the election he failed to point out that John Kerry would close tax loopholes that incent corporations to move operations to other countries. That is a HUGE differenc ebetweent he candidates which Dobbs hid.

Furthermore, he toes the line and never states HIS oppinion about CAFTA. CAFTA will be a further extension of the disasterous NAFTA. While illegal immigration is a problem, the corporate ownership of our government and its trade laws are the reasons for mass job loss in the US.
 
Post a Comment

Links to this post:

Create a Link



<< Home

This page is powered by Blogger. Isn't yours?